l o o k i n g c l o s e r

 < back

respond to the review


guest review:

The Protector

a review by Greg Wright

Copyright © 2006 by Jeffrey Overstreet. Reproduction is forbidden without permission of the author.
Contact Jeffrey Overstreet at joverstreet@gmail.com.
 

In Thai, with English subtitles

Director - Prachya Pinkaew

Writers - Napalee, Piyaros Thongdee, Joe Wannapin and Kongdej Jaturanrasmee, based on a story by Prachya Pinkaew

Director of photography - Nuttawut Kittikun

Music by the RZA

Production designer - Akadech Kaewkot

Martial arts choreographers - Tony Jaa and Panna Rittikrai

Produced by Prachya Pinkaew and Sukanya Vongsthapat

Weinstein Company. 84 minutes. Rated R for martial-arts violence.

STARRING: Tony Jaa (Kham), Phetthai Wongkhamlao (Mark), Bongkod Kongmalai (Pla), Jin Xing (Madame Rose), Nathan B. Jones (T K) and JohnnyTri Nguyen (Johnny).


Some films are enjoyable on their own terms and defy scholarly critique. The Protector is one of these.

In terms of cinematic conventions, the film offers little in the way of character development; action sequences are strung together with seemingly minimal concern for narrative flow; dubbed dialogue rarely matches up to the movements of actors’ mouths, even when their lips actually form English words; individual shots within individual scenes suggest the work of seven or eight different production designers. Heck, The Protector plays like a low-budget, third-world homage to Tarantino-Rodriguez collaborative paeans to pulp cinema. It’s a pastiche of cult-film references, from Lee and Chan to Mad Max, from the World Wrestling Federation to the World Wildlife Federation, from Crouching Tiger to Two Brothers. Huh.

But none of that really matters. In part it’s because director-producer Prachya Pinkaew puts all those familiar elements into a new and interesting setting. The central conflict, which involves a murder and the theft of two elephants, is established in rural Thailand instead of Hong Kong or Shanghai. Then when Tony Jaa, as Kham, sets out to wreak revenge, the trail takes him to Australia, where the animals are being utilized in a truly diabolical manner, one that is disgustingly villainous and original.

Naturally, Jaa emerges victorious through the power of loyalty and mere flesh (and bones).

Also, The Protector works in part because Pinkaew stages visually stunning action sequences.

As I typed that last sentence, the film’s trailer ran again during the third quarter of the Steelers-Dolphins game, and I couldn’t take my eyes off it. Nine tenths of the movie is like the trailer. Seriously. This is not one of those films where the trailer shows you all the best parts. Not by a long shot.

In one early fight sequence, Jaa out-Chans Jackie Chan in a lengthy and tightly choreographed fight that weaves in and out of three abandoned streetcars. Later, the ante is unbelievably upped when Jaa battles his way through literally dozens of adversaries, all while ascending some six or seven levels of a restaurant club in a single tracking shot that takes up almost an entire reel. No kidding. By the end of the shot, you can tell that Jaa has been pushed to his utmost physical limit, but the shot is flawless in its execution.

And there are still two mind-boggling fight sequences to go.

If you see The Protector, see it with an audience. And see it with an audience that loves martial arts films, if you can. Even if you don’t enjoy martial arts pictures, you will gain some appreciation for why a lot of people do and you will thoroughly enjoy the audience reaction, even if you don’t enjoy the film itself.

 

Greg Wright is the author of two books: Tolkien in Perspective and Peter Jackson in Perspective.

For more information on Greg Wright, including his email address, check out his Blogger profile page.